Joseph Braude: The Persian Spring’s Pro-Israel Herald?
In a November 12 article in Tablet Magazine entitled “Saudis’ Proxy War Against Iran,” Joseph Braude writes:
Extensive reporting from local sources in Saudi Arabia and the Gulf states reveals that several countries surrounding Iran are beginning to back the country’s ethnic dissidents as a way of waging a proxy war against the mullahs. In Saudi Arabia, media and clerical elites recently mobilized to raise public awareness about the situation of Ahwazi Arabs, frame their cause as a national liberation struggle, and urge Arabs and Muslims to support them. Saudi donors are providing money and technological support to Ahwazi dissidents seeking to wage their own public information campaign, calling on Ahwazis to rise up against their rulers. The Saudi initiatives, in turn, join ongoing ventures by Azerbaijan and Iraq’s Kurdistan Regional Government to organize and train other dissident groups
.Hinting at his agenda in writing the piece, Braude adds:
“These players seem poised to escalate in the months to come, whether Americans or Israelis attempt to work with them or not.”
Then, in a rhetorical style reminiscent of think tank fellows affecting objectivity as they strive to influence U.S. Middle East policy in a pro-Israel direction, Braude concludes on an ostensibly cautious note, weaving both idealist and realist strands into his argument:
This regional proxy war, now escalating, is morally questionable: Should ethnic groups’ legitimate political aspirations be exploited for other purposes? Should attacks on civilian targets, such as mosques, ever be sanctioned? It is also strategically questionable: Will some of these dissidents go on to support a radical agenda and attack the West? Is the fragmenting of Iran into several states in the long-term interest of the region and the United States.? For all its tradeoffs, it belongs in both the public discussion and the quieter conversations about our next steps on Iran policy.
However, if the experience of Iraq, Libya and Syria is any guide, that “public discussion” and those “quieter conversations” will amount to little more than Israel partisans advising American policymakers that their next steps should be to “work with” the Saudi-backed Iranian dissidents as part of the broader Israeli-driven campaign of, what Braude describes as, “bleeding the regime.”While the piece appears in “a daily online magazine of Jewish news, ideas, and culture” which features some of America’s staunchest supporters of Israel, the author’s bio offers no definitive indication of a pro-Israel agenda:Joseph Braude, a Middle East specialist, broadcasts a weekly commentary in Arabic on Morocco’s Radio MED network. He is the author, most recently, of The Honored Dead: A Story of Friendship, Murder, and the Search for Truth in the Arab World.On closer inspection, however, the Middle East specialist’s “search for truth in the Arab world” would appear to be somewhat less than disinterested.
Iraqi forces free hundreds of civilians in Mosul Old City battles as death toll mounts - Iraqi forces opened exit routes for hundreds of civilians to flee the Old City of Mosul on Saturday as they battled to retake the ancient quarter from IS...
36 minutes ago